National Pie Day is Jan. 23. Here are the best pies in the Illinois Valley

National Pie Day is Thursday, Jan. 23, which marks a delicious occasion to indulge in this classic dessert, from the comforting apple pie to the decadent pecan pie.

Whether you’re baking a masterpiece at home or enjoying a slice from your favorite local bakery, this day is a reminder to savor the joy of freshly-baked pie.

To find out where to get the best pie in the Illinois Valley, we asked our readers to weigh in for the Shaw Local Best of the Illinois Valley contest. The results are in, and here are the top-rated pie shops, as voted by audiences.

BEST PIE: Myrtle’s Pies, 927 N. Main St., Princeton

A charming small-town bakery and cafe, Myrtle’s Pies is know for friendly service and delicious homemade pies. Varieties include classic fruit pies like apple, cherry, rhubarb and blueberry lavender to decadent varieties like coconut cream, chocolate peanut butter pie, French Silk, German chocolate pie and many more unique flavors. Myrtle’s also offers baked goods like cookies, cinnamon rolls and more. Whole pies and slices are available daily. Call ahead for special orders.

NOTE: According to Myrtle’s Facebook page, the bakery is temporarily closed until Feb.13.

ONE OF THE BEST: Spring Valley Bakery, 119 W. St. Paul St., Spring Valley

Spring Valley Bakery, which also won Best Bakery in the 2024 Best of the Illinois Valley, carries a variety of pies, including blueberry, apple, cherry, French Silk, Oreo, Turtle and more, including seasonal favorites. The bakery is also known for their freshly-baked doughnuts, cookies, Danishes and more. Visit Spring Valley Bakery’s Facebook page for more information.

ONE OF THE BEST: The Ottawa Bakery, 630 Court St., Ottawa

The Ottawa Bakery is known for its made-from-scratch cookies, pastries, cakes, muffins and pies. Visit their Facebook page for more information.